Paris is Burning (1991) / Is Paris Burning? (1944) from 1992 is the first work in the exhibition, occupying the ground floor space. The work has not been shown publicly since Kilimnik’s very first museum show at the ICA Philadelphia in 1992. It is an important example of her early sculptural work – a genre for which she gained attention in the late 1980s alongside artists such as Mike Kelley and Cady Noland. Other early examples include The Joker Episode of the Avengers (1991) – part of a series of works based on the British television series The Avengers. In the work on view, an assortment of objects is displayed throughout the exhibition space, seemingly at random, giving the illusion of an abandoned stage set or a display in a store window. On the back wall, the two halves of the work’s title are announced in bold white typeface on black posters, simulating the cards used in silent movies as well as the aesthetic in Jennie Livingstone’s 1990 documentary, Paris is Burning. At a remove from each other, the titles indicate two narrative frames for the incongruous props and posters that appear around them. On the left, ‘Is Paris Burning?’ Refers to a Hollywood movie from 1966 that centred on Hitler’s real-life plans to destroy Paris in 1944, hours before it was liberated from Nazi rule. Meanwhile on the right, Kilimnik uses the aforementioned documentary that followed the thriving ball culture engendered by New York City’s African-American, Latino, gay, and transgender communities. The films collide in the installation: the stigmatic symbol of the swastika brands a red dress like a flag, and is displayed with a bandaged leg, skis, tights, a jacket, and other costume and fashion items. The props appear to be selected from the historic and recent past to overlap in a disconcerting mise en scène of twentieth century experience. On the left, photos are displayed from the Hollywood movie, showing cities ravaged by bombs and battles in the Second World War. On the right, ball vocabulary appears with the names of the most illustrious New York drag ‘houses’. Kilimnik uses the idea of the stage set to re-present icons of evil as adornment, fashion and fascism, and to present historical fact as theatre. Through presenting these two discordant areas of history – war-torn Europe and countercultural New York, she examines how cultures are established through varying means.
Kilimnik’s theme of the Second World War continues in the next room. Paintings of fighter planes and studies of military horses are treated with a lightness of colour and ease of brushstroke that sometimes transforms their subject matter into décor. Elsewhere, an early series of maps is shown alongside a new, much larger series that at first glance looks like abstract paintings. The Battle for France is plotted in one, accompanied by a series of handwritten notes explaining battle plans. In another, she comments on the visual prettiness of the colours and shapes, deliberately subsuming the trauma and devastation they identify into a prettier, more appealing surface. Kilimnik’s works are often saturated with these double meanings – innocence and cynicism, fantasy and reality, the everyday and infamy. Upstairs, the works reveal her fascination with cultural history. Copies of the work of earlier artists abound, such as Scottish artist Sir Henry Raeburn, as well as French Rococo painter Jean Baptiste Oudry. The early drawing My Sister and Me by Sir Thomas Lawrence (1986) is a copy in pastel of a painting by Sir Thomas Lawrence, whilst another early pastel is a copy of a work by the eighteenth century French artist, Jean-Baptiste Greuze. They, along with the later ‘Doll’ paintings, and photographs, attest to Kilimnik’s instrumental development of the new tendency in figurative painting, as well as her continued interest in the components that have formed cultural identity through the ages. In her works, the structuring factors of culture are shown to be myriad and unexpected: from regional borders, to regional dress, landscapes, mythology, witchcraft, stagecraft, the big screen and the small screen.